Does Social Security Owe you Money?
Over 1 million Unpaid SSI underpayments identified
In August 2026, the Social Security Administration (SSA) Office of the Inspector General (OIG) released a report from an audit that found SSA failed to issue underpayments to 1.1 million individuals who receive Supplemental Security Income (SSI) benefits. When conducting the audit, SSA’s OIG reviewed 160 of 2.5 million underpayments on SSI records as of September 2024. They found that SSA employees failed to follow agency policies and issue underpayments owed to SSI recipients 43% of the time. This resulted in an estimated 610,165 underpayments owed to living recipients and another 444,265 owed to eligible survivors of deceased recipients.
SSI is a needs-based program paid to disabled and elderly individuals who have limited income and resources. In 2026, the maximum monthly benefit amount paid to an SSI recipient is $994. Recipients cannot have more than $2,000 in resources such as bank accounts; real estate, other than their primary home; or a second vehicle.
Underpayments occur for a variety of reasons. For example, a newly eligible recipient may be due payment from the time of his application through his disability approval. Since SSI benefits fluctuate based on the amount of any other income to the recipient, an established recipient may be due an underpayment for months she was paid less than she was due because the earlier payments were issued using estimated wages or unearned income. Underpayments are generally issued in a maximum of three installments, separated by six months, when the amount owed is more than three months of the maximum benefit amount.
SSA’s failure to pay underpayments can affect a recipient’s ability to meet their basic needs. Ultimately, it could be the difference between stability and crisis when an unexpected need arises for someone who is already managing to live on a needs-based benefit.
What can you do if you are owed an SSI underpayment?
- Make a written request to SSA for the amount you are owed. Be as specific as possible. Send a photocopy of any letters or decisions showing you’re eligible for payment along with your request. If you can’t find the document, check the notices in your Social Security online account. If it isn’t there, provide as much information as you can remember (i.e. approximate date, the reason you were underpaid, etc.).
- Make sure to save proof of your request to SSA. You can do this by uploading the document through your online account account. You can also fax your request (keep the confirmation!) or submit it by visiting your local office. Be sure to ask for a receipt or a date stamped copy of the document if you take it into an office.
- If you haven’t received a response in six weeks, follow up with your local office for status. Social Security employees have extremely demanding workloads on top of taking interviews and answering phones. Please always be kind when interacting with them.
If you need help with an SSI underpayment or another Social Security issue, please click the contact button to schedule a free case evaluation.
*This article is for informational purposes only and is not intended to constitute legal advice. Reading this post or communicating with me does not create an attorney-client relationship. An attorney-client relationship is established only though a formal agreement for legal representation. Social Security rules and policies may change. The information may not apply to your specific circumstances. Please submit a request for consultation to discuss your specific needs.

